Dunnes Stores Belfast cycling facilities

Over November and December 2015, Northern Ireland Greenways surveyed cycling facilities at the 40 chain supermarkets in Belfast. Dunnes Stores’ 2 major (grocery) supermarkets were included, along with the flagship city centre Food Hall on Cornmarket.

superrank

This system means we can independently rate any supermarket against a consistent benchmark out of 7 points for the quality of facilities laid on for customers choosing to arrive by bicycle.  A score of 6-7 would identify a store offering adequate to good facilities. So how does each Dunnes Stores location in Belfast rate for cycling facilities?


Dunnes Stores Annadale

1Point

This is a whopper of a disappointment. Why? This decades-old Dunnes supermarket sits right in the middle of Belfast’s Cycling Revolution, in the Ballynafeigh ward with cycling at over 6% share of journeys to work, the best in the whole country.

image

So with a spacious (and barely ever full) car park out front, there is.. one cycle hoop next to the store. Again there’s no clear ownership by Dunnes so no extra point for quality, and the dark spot would make anyone think twice before leaving their bike.

image

Expecting shoppers to latch their bicycles up onto the car park fence (as is common) just isn’t good enough. This should be a class-leading location.


Dunnes Stores Cornmarket

2Points

Like Marks and Spencer around the corner, Dunnes may be benefiting from a little bit of government-provided good fortune here – so no additional points for quality.

image

However the prime location outside the store makes this a great option for shoppers.


Dunnes Stores Park Centre

3Points

Good fortune or not – who knows? Either way the site beside the entrance and decent quality mean Dunnes and Iceland have to split the credit here. It’s a moot point as this Dunnes is closing, which is a major blow to Park Centre and the local community.

image

Shelter and CCTV, along with another rack at the second entrance would be useful additions for Iceland and if another supermarket anchor tenant moves in.


What Dunnes Stores says..

No comment received.


Verdict

DunnesRank

Dunnes Stores could be very lucky here – you couldn’t say for certain that any of these bike racks were installed at the behest of Dunnes, and yet the 3 Belfast stores get an average score of 2 points out of 7. Annadale sticks out like a sore thumb and better use could be made of the car park to attract some of the hundreds of people cycling past every day.


How does Dunnes Stores rank for bicycle facilities against other supermarkets in Belfast in 2015? Find out in Store Wars VII: The Cycling Revolution Awakens..

Note: Visits to each of the 40 supermarkets in Belfast were made in November and December 2015 and facilities (or lack of) were recorded as observed at the time – NI Greenways is happy to correct any errors identified in this survey.

4 thoughts on “Dunnes Stores Belfast cycling facilities

  1. The hoop at Annadale, like the one you mention at Iceland Bridge Street in that article, belongs to Transport NI – it’s something they’ve attached to a number of signposts around Belfast for the benefit of local shoppers.

    Rather than repeat myself over there, I think it’s worth noting that stores like Iceland in Bridge Street, Marks & Spencer in Donegall Place and Dunnes in Cornmarket/Ann Street don’t have the luxury of owning any form of plaza as Tesco does in Royal Avenue. it’s fair to judge Annadale and shopping centres for lack of cycling provision against car provision, but in the city centre the stores aren’t discriminating when they don’t have space to do something for cyclists themselves.

    1. Thanks for taking the time to comment Andy.

      It was a judgement call from the beginning to include one ‘main’ city centre location for any of the big 7 chains – definitely the character of the stores is different from those on arterial roads and suburbs. However, there’s little difference in the needs of customers when wanting to visit by bicycle.

      I considered corralling them into a separate post. What changed my mind was the Lidl store on High Street, which included 3 bicycle racks in its planning application. If these (self-installed) racks had actually seen the light of day, it would put that store on a par with any other in the city, and the same survey benchmarks would apply.

      So the question is, if Lidl can do it (even if they didn’t in the end) what’s stopping Tesco Metro, Iceland Bridge Street (or Castle Street), M&S (thinking on the City Hall / Callender Street sides) or Dunnes Cornmarket from putting in some innovative cycle parking solutions? Or working with DSD/Council for special consideration when Streets Ahead or similar schemes are reworking the streetscape?

      You’re absolutely right that the comparison with car parking seen elsewhere doesn’t hold up in the city centre, and I hope it doesn’t come across that way in the posts. Apart from adjacent multi-storey car parks, getting a bicycle to any of these stores is much handier than driving.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s